Finding the perfect brunch spot in Sarasota, FL, can transform a simple weekend into a memorable local experience. From cozy cafes tucked along vibrant streets to elegant eateries overlooking scenic views, this city offers a breakfast and brunch scene that’s both diverse and inviting. Over years of exploring Sarasota’s culinary gems, I’ve noticed that the best brunches balance quality, atmosphere, and a touch of uniqueness—thinking beyond basic eggs and toast.
Imagine sitting down to a well-crafted dish that pairs fresh ingredients with creative flair, all served in a setting that feels both welcoming and distinctive. Whether you crave a hearty Southern-style plate or something more refined, Sarasota’s brunch spots cater to every taste. Dive into this guide and discover the eateries that truly elevate brunch to an art form in this charming Florida city.
Where to find the best brunch in Sarasota, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best brunch in Sarasota, FL:
- Millie’s
- First Watch
- Blue Dolphin Cafe
- Rosemary And Thyme
- Original Word of Mouth
- Libby’s Neighborhood Brasserie
- Eleni’s Pizza Works
- Der Dutchman
- The Breakfast House
- First Watch
1. Millie’s
Nestled on Clark Road, Millie’s is a favorite among locals seeking a welcoming brunch spot with diverse options. Its warm, inviting atmosphere is perfect for enjoying a relaxed weekend meal. With a focus on quality and inclusivity, Millie’s offers vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices that do not compromise on flavor.
During my visit, I was impressed by their creative menu, particularly the avocado toast topped with fresh herbs and a poached egg — a simple dish but executed with remarkable finesse. For a hearty option, their Breakfast Burrito packs flavor and satisfying components, showcasing Millie’s commitment to fresh ingredients and thoughtful preparation. It’s a place that truly caters to all tastes, making every brunch feel special.
2. First Watch
Located in the heart of Sarasota on Main Street, First Watch impresses with its clean, bright setting and a menu that strikes the right balance between comfort and creativity. The staff are genuinely welcoming, which adds to the laid-back vibe. It’s ideal if you’re looking for a spot that values fresh ingredients and a seasonally inspired menu.
During my last brunch there, I ordered the Tri-Athlete Omelet — a protein-packed choice with egg whites, vegetables, and fresh fruit on the side. It felt light but filling, and it highlighted their attention to balanced meals. For something more indulgent, their Lemon Ricotta Pancakes bring a subtle sweetness that doesn’t overpower.
First Watch stands out for its commitment to wholesome food made right when you order. Whether you’re in for a quick meal or a long catch-up, it delivers quality every time.
3. Blue Dolphin Cafe
Blue Dolphin Cafe, tucked into the bustle of St. Armands Circle, feels like a neighborhood secret that everyone’s in on. It’s small, casual, and unpretentious — the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name and newcomers are welcomed with a smile. The vibe is classic diner, but the menu leans more thoughtful than greasy spoon.
What makes this spot stand out is its ability to deliver comfort food with a light touch. I once stopped in after a morning walk on Lido Beach and ordered the Blue Dolphin Special — two eggs, pancakes, and home fries. The pancakes were golden and fluffy, and the home fries had just the right crisp. It was simple, but done right.
If you’re in the mood for something with a twist, try the Blue Crab Omelet. It’s a local favorite that captures the coastal charm of Sarasota without going overboard. Pair it with a side of fresh fruit, and you’ve got a brunch that’s both satisfying and balanced.
With vegetarian and gluten-free options available, Blue Dolphin Cafe caters to a wide range of tastes. It’s not flashy, but it’s consistent — and that’s what keeps people coming back.
4. Rosemary And Thyme
Rosemary And Thyme on North Orange Avenue is a charming spot that combines a cozy atmosphere with a menu full of fresh, flavorful options. Its welcoming vibe makes it a perfect place for a relaxed brunch, whether with friends or solo. The restaurant’s focus on quality ingredients shines through in every dish.
On a recent visit, I tried their Vegetable Frittata, filled with seasonal produce and topped with herbed goat cheese — a testament to their dedication to wholesome, creative cooking. The presentation was inviting, and the flavors were well-balanced. For something sweet, the Blueberry Lemon Pancakes offered just the right touch of tartness and sweetness.
What sets Rosemary And Thyme apart is its emphasis on accommodating dietary preferences without sacrificing taste. With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, it’s a versatile choice for a satisfying brunch that reflects Sarasota’s vibrant culinary scene.
5. Original Word of Mouth
Original Word of Mouth has long been celebrated as Sarasota’s best breakfast spot, thanks to its commitment to using fresh, quality ingredients daily. This family-owned restaurant offers a warm, hometown feel that makes every visit feel like a special occasion. Its inviting atmosphere is perfect for relaxed mornings with friends or family.
During my visit, I enjoyed the Challah French Toast, which was thick, fluffy, and topped with fresh berries — a perfect example of their dedication to flavor and presentation. For a savory option, the Breakfast Burrito was hearty and loaded with fresh ingredients, reflecting their emphasis on wholesome, satisfying meals.
What truly makes Original Word of Mouth stand out is their consistency and genuine service. With a menu accommodating vegetarians and gluten-free diners, it’s a reliable choice for a memorable Sarasota brunch experience.
6. Libby’s Neighborhood Brasserie
Libby’s Neighborhood Brasserie offers a fresh take on modern American dining in Sarasota, with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that immediately feels like home. Its recent redesign highlights an inviting interior, where guests can enjoy the lively energy of an open kitchen—a feature that adds excitement to every visit. Named after a beloved family matriarch, Libby’s reflects a blend of style, comfort, and community spirit.
During my visit, I was drawn to their Famous Lemon Ricotta Pancakes, which were light, fluffy, and bursting with citrus flavor—perfect for brunch. For a savory option, their Steak and Egg Hash paired tender steak with crispy potatoes and fresh herbs, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor.
Libby’s stands out for its commitment to accommodating different dietary needs, offering vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free choices. It’s a modern yet cozy spot that promises both memorable dishes and genuine hospitality.
7. Eleni’s Pizza Works
Eleni’s Pizza Works is celebrated for bringing authentic New England Greek-style pizza to Sarasota. This family-owned gem offers a welcoming environment where quality ingredients shine in every dish. Their dedication to freshness and flavor makes it a top choice for brunch and beyond.
On a recent visit, I enjoyed their Greek-Style Breakfast Pizza, topped with feta, spinach, and tomatoes—a perfect blend of breakfast and pizza for a satisfying start to the day. Their fresh salads and hearty pasta dishes also showcase their commitment to quality and authentic flavors.
What sets Eleni’s apart is its focus on delivering a taste of New England with a local touch, all while accommodating vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. It’s ideal for anyone craving a unique brunch experience with a comforting twist.
8. Der Dutchman
If you’re in Sarasota and craving a hearty, satisfying brunch with a touch of Amish tradition, Der Dutchman is a solid pick. The spacious dining area buzzes with the gentle hum of comfort food seekers, and service moves with practiced warmth.
What makes Der Dutchman stand out is its commitment to scratch-made dishes rooted in Midwestern hospitality. On my last visit, I opted for their vegetarian skillet, layered with perfectly crisp potatoes, sautéed veggies, and two eggs cooked just right. It was filling but not heavy, and each bite had real flavor.
Don’t miss their house-made pastries and pies, which double as brunch dessert or the perfect takeaway treat. Whether you’re vegetarian, gluten-free, or just hungry, this spot delivers honest food done well.
9. The Breakfast House
The Breakfast House feels like brunch in a friend’s backyard—if your friend happened to be a skilled cook with a flair for pancakes. Nestled in a charming Key West-style bungalow, it’s a cozy spot where locals linger under shady trees and sip coffee with ease.
What sets it apart is the menu’s balance of comfort and creativity. I tried the Island Cakes, a trio of fluffy pancakes with coconut, grilled pineapple, and macadamia nuts. They were light, flavorful, and unlike anything else in town. For something savory, the Tuscan Benedict—with spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, and pesto hollandaise—was a standout.
Service is warm, and the garden seating adds a relaxed charm. Whether you’re vegan, gluten-free, or just brunch-obsessed, this place delivers.
10. First Watch
Best Brunch in Sarasota, FL
Sarasota knows how to do brunch. Whether you’re craving something cozy, looking for farm-fresh fare, or simply want to sip something iced while watching palm trees sway, this Gulf Coast city has you covered. Here’s a curated list of brunch spots that have locals returning and visitors lingering just a bit longer.
1. Millie’s
A longtime local favorite, Millie’s combines charm with consistently good food. Their breakfast potatoes are famous, and the menu leans heavily on homestyle options with a Southern tilt. Come early; the crowd proves it’s worth the wait.
2. First Watch
Reliable and health-forward, First Watch is a well-loved chain that originated in Florida. With fresh juices, seasonal menus, and hearty portions, it’s ideal for a feel-good start to the day.
3. Blue Dolphin Cafe
Tucked on St. Armands Circle, this unpretentious spot is great for classic diner-style fare. The portions are generous, the pancakes draw rave reviews, and the outdoor seating seals the deal.
4. Rosemary and Thyme
For something polished but not stuffy, Rosemary and Thyme delivers thoughtful plates in a breezy space. Their take on omelets and tartines proves that simple can still be satisfying.
5. Original Word of Mouth
This place is casual, but the food is anything but ordinary. Expect fresh-baked goods, rotating specials, and excellent coffee. Their banana granola pancakes deserve a mention.
6. Libby’s Neighborhood Brasserie
Libby’s brunch offers a slightly more upscale experience without losing that neighborhood feel. The setting is sleek, and the menu doesn’t shy away from bold flavors. Try the avocado toast—it’s a standout.
7. Eleni’s Pizza Works
Pizza for brunch? Surprisingly, yes. Eleni’s is the dark horse of the bunch, serving Mediterranean-inspired brunch options in addition to their signature pies.
8. Der Dutchman
Hearty, traditional, and family-friendly. Der Dutchman serves comforting Amish-style meals, complete with baked goods that could double as souvenirs.
9. The Breakfast House
A whimsical cottage with a menu to match. From crabless Benedict to plant-forward options, it’s where charm meets quality.
10. First Watch (Again)
Yes, it’s worth a second nod. With multiple locations across Sarasota, it’s a consistent crowd-pleaser that adapts well to each neighborhood.
11. Sunnyside Cafe
Clean, airy, and with an emphasis on healthy options. They’re known for gluten-free pancakes and a veggie-packed brunch lineup.
12. Café on St. Armands
More than just location, this café offers strong espresso, flaky pastries, and a menu that feels light but satisfying.
13. Connors Steak & Seafood
A less traditional pick, but brunch here surprises with refined touches. Think more surf than turf, but with robust flavors.
14. Dutch Valley Restaurant
Affordable, quick, and consistent. Dutch Valley brings Midwestern diner vibes and a no-fuss approach to brunch.
15. Circo
Not your typical brunch spot. Known for tacos and tostadas, Circo’s weekend menu dips into brunch with fusion flair.
16. Grillsmith – Siesta Key Gateway
Comfort food meets polished presentation. Their brunch burger and skillet eggs bring flair to the table.
17. Yoder’s Restaurant
Another Amish staple, known best for its pies. The cinnamon rolls here are brunch-worthy on their own.
18. Simon’s Coffee House
Health-conscious without being restrictive. Vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free dishes get equal attention—and flavor.
19. Green Zebra Cafe
This one’s for the green juice crowd, but their brunch bowls and wraps hit the spot for everyone. Chic and relaxed with plenty of plant-based options.
20. Lovely Square
A boutique café with a strong French influence. Their quiches and galettes keep regulars coming back.
21. La Creperie Caffe
Crepes both sweet and savory fill the menu here. The Parisian ambiance makes it feel like a weekend escape.
22. Rendez-vous French Bakery
Freshly baked pastries, buttery croissants, and espresso done right. Low-key, authentic, and satisfying.
23. Mattison’s City Grille
Outdoor tables, live music, and a brunch menu that mixes international flavors. Great for a lively atmosphere without the crowd.
24. Crab & Fin
Seafood takes center stage here. A coastal option with elegant brunch entrées and a stellar raw bar.
25. Station 400
Set in a historic train depot, Station 400 serves locally sourced dishes with rustic charm. Their lemon ricotta pancakes are noteworthy.
26. Bob’s Train
Dine in vintage train cars and enjoy a brunch menu that mixes whimsy with classic fare. It’s a Sarasota original.
27. Madfish Grill
More than just seafood, their brunch lineup leans into comfort with hearty portions and a solid coffee game.
28. C’est La Vie
Lively, bustling, and very French. The bakery counter tempts while the full menu offers bistro favorites.
29. OfKors Bakery
Clean ingredients, flavorful results. OfKors is focused on artisan breads and subtly creative brunch plates.
30. The Serving Spoon
Unpretentious with a local following. Expect big breakfasts, hot coffee, and a menu that satisfies standard cravings.
Frequently Asked Questions
What time is brunch served in Sarasota?
Most places serve brunch between 9 a.m. and 2 p.m., especially on weekends. Always check local hours.
Are there halal or haram-free options?
Yes. Several restaurants offer vegetarian or seafood-only dishes that align with halal-friendly preferences. Always confirm ingredients with staff.
Is there brunch near Siesta Key?
Plenty. Station 400, First Watch, and Grillsmith are just a short drive from the beach.
Do I need reservations?
For weekend brunch, a reservation never hurts. Popular spots like Millie’s and Der Dutchman fill up fast.
More Things to Try in Sarasota, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the typical brunch hours in Sarasota?
Most restaurants serve brunch from around 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. on weekends. However, hours can vary, so it’s best to check the specific place’s schedule ahead of time.
Are there vegetarian or vegan-friendly brunch options in Sarasota?
Yes, many spots cater to vegetarian and vegan diets, offering plant-based dishes, salads, and egg or seafood options that align with various dietary preferences. Always ask about ingredient modifications if needed.
Can I find gluten-free brunch dishes in Sarasota?
Absolutely. Several restaurants include gluten-free options like breakfast bowls, pancakes, and bread, making it easier for guests with gluten sensitivities to enjoy brunch.
Do I need reservations for brunch in Sarasota?
Weekend brunch can be popular, especially at places like Millie’s or First Watch. Making a reservation helps avoid long waits, but many spots accept walk-ins as well.
Are there brunch spots near Siesta Key?
Yes, several options like Station 400 and First Watch are nearby, offering easy access to the beach area for a relaxing brunch after a morning in the sun.