Brunch in Custer, SD, has always felt like a small adventure to me. Every local spot carries its own charm—some greet you with the warm aroma of fresh pastries, others start your morning with the sizzle of eggs on a griddle. With the Black Hills as a backdrop, even a simple cup of coffee seems to taste better. There’s something special about gathering for a late morning meal surrounded by great views and genuine hospitality.
If you’re on the hunt for the best brunch in Custer, you’re in the right hands. I’ve spent weekends venturing through the town’s diners, bakeries, and coffee shops, searching for that perfect blend of tasty plates and relaxed atmosphere. This guide will point you toward the local favorites—the quiet gems and lively spots that make brunch in Custer worth extending your stay. Each place promises hearty, satisfying options that are sure to start your day right.
1. Baker’s Bakery & Cafe
Baker’s Bakery & Cafe feels like the heart of Custer’s brunch scene. The first time I stepped in, the scent of fresh-baked bread pretty much made any other plans disappear. It’s family-run, cozy, and the staff seem to know their regulars by name. The glass cases piled with pastries and donuts are hard to resist.
What sets this spot apart is their homemade bread. Almost every dish, from hefty breakfast sandwiches to classic toast and eggs, comes with slices thick enough to be memorable. Their cinnamon rolls are a local legend—soft, sticky, and perfect with a cup of coffee.
If you’re looking for a typical brunch, try the breakfast burrito or their veggie omelet—fresh, filling, and with bread that actually matters. Baker’s makes a simple morning special in all the best ways.
2. Blue Bell Lodge – Tatanka Dining
Blue Bell Lodge’s Tatanka Dining gives brunch a Western twist you won’t find anywhere else in Custer. I remember sitting on their patio early one morning, with French Creek in the background, feeling like brunch had suddenly leveled up. The rustic lodge setting feels charmingly off-the-grid yet inviting, perfect for a slow start to your day.
The menu skews hearty and classic. Their fluffy pancakes and skillet breakfasts are local favorites, and you can always count on eggs done just right. For something distinct, the vegetarian omelet loaded with fresh veggies lets you skip the cliché while still getting that ranch-house feel.
If you have extra time, try their patio seating—the scenery is a perfect match for a leisurely meal. Every bite feels like you’re truly in the Black Hills.
3. Miner’s Cup Coffee Co
Miner’s Cup Coffee Co turns your brunch into a grab-and-go delight. There was a cool morning when I rolled through their drive-thru, half-awake, and left with coffee that made me wish I’d ordered two. This place is quick, friendly, and beloved for its locally roasted beans.
Unlike your usual sit-down brunch, Miner’s Cup is all about convenience without sacrificing quality. The breakfast menu is always available—think egg sandwiches piled high on soft bread or wraps filled with fresh veggies. Their pastries are just the right kind of sweet, perfect for pairing with a bold espresso or smooth frappe.
Try their breakfast burrito for something filling or a fruit smoothie if you want something lighter. Miner’s Cup is the go-to spot when you want brunch on your own schedule—with plenty of flavor in every bite.
4. Buglin’ Bull Restaurant & Sports
Buglin’ Bull Restaurant & Sports brings a lively vibe to brunch in downtown Custer. I once stopped in on game day and found the energy infectious, with locals catching up over coffee and plates piled high. The mix of sports bar buzz and family-friendly comfort makes this spot feel welcoming, no matter your mood.
The brunch menu is broad and creative. You’ll find hearty classics like omelets and pancakes, but the real draw is the regional touch. Try their walleye or bison options for flavors unique to South Dakota. Salads and wraps round out the menu, so everyone can find their favorite.
For something memorable, order the veggie omelet or a fresh breakfast wrap. Buglin’ Bull turns the weekend meal into a fun, friendly event for visitors and locals alike.
5. Our Place
+1 605-673-5255
Our Place is the kind of diner you stumble into once and then make a habit of returning. The morning I sat at their counter, the staff greeted everyone like old friends—even those of us just passing through. This spot keeps things classic and unfussy, with generous portions and friendly service leading the way.
Breakfast is served strong and simple. Their omelets come packed, the hash browns are golden and crisp, and pancakes arrive stacked and fluffy. You won’t find many frills, but the honest flavors more than make up for it.
If you want something that feels like home, try their veggie omelet or a traditional breakfast plate. Our Place is for anyone who loves the basics, done just right.
6. Powder House Restaurant
Powder House Restaurant feels both special and unpretentious, tucked just minutes from Mount Rushmore. My first brunch visit started with the lodge’s cozy, wood-beamed dining room. This place blends mountain history with true hospitality, making it a memorable stop in the Black Hills.
The brunch menu here embraces comfort and variety. Fluffy pancakes, omelets stuffed with fresh veggies, and golden hash browns anchor the classics. Not many spots can match their homemade breads, which show up alongside almost every plate.
If you’re seeking something unique, try the veggie omelet or their well-built breakfast sandwich. Powder House’s hearty plates and rustic setting make it a favorite for locals and travelers alike, especially if you want to savor brunch near some of South Dakota’s most iconic sights.
Frequently Asked Questions
What time do brunch spots in Custer, SD usually open?
Most brunch spots in Custer open early, around 6:30 or 7:00 a.m. Some venues adjust hours seasonally, so check before heading out, especially in winter.
Are there vegetarian or vegan brunch options in Custer?
Yes, several places like Baker’s Bakery & Cafe and Miner’s Cup Coffee Co offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly dishes, such as veggie omelets, salads, and wraps.
Can I find gluten-free choices for brunch in Custer?
You’ll spot gluten-free options on most brunch menus, including gluten-free breads, omelets, and fresh salads. Just mention your preference when ordering.
Is it necessary to make a reservation for brunch?
Most spots in Custer are casual and walk-in friendly. For larger groups or peak tourist months, it’s smart to call ahead, especially at popular places like Powder House Restaurant.
Are there any brunch spots with outdoor seating in Custer?
Yes, spots like Blue Bell Lodge offer inviting patios—perfect for relaxing with a meal and enjoying the Black Hills scenery.