If there’s one meal that Selden handles with surprising charm, it’s brunch. You won’t need to consult a complicated map or decipher cryptic menus here. Instead, you’re met by a lineup of spots that keep things simple and delicious, balancing classic comfort with a few unexpected twists. More than once, I’ve set out on a lazy Sunday, convinced I’d just grab a quick bagel, only to end up falling for a velvety omelet at a tucked-away café or sipping a smoothie that tastes like a short vacation.
Finding the best brunch in Selden is like solving a riddle where every answer is a reward. There’s something for everyone, whether you crave a hearty plate of eggs, a flaky croissant, or the perfect sweet and savory pairing. This guide will help you sort through the local gems and familiar favorites, steering you away from the forgettable and straight to the satisfying. The goal? Helping you land your next favorite brunch spot without second-guessing.
Where to find the best brunch in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best brunch in Selden, NY:
- Crazy Crepe Cafe
- Cella Bagel
- Tropical Smoothie Cafe
- Caffe Amici
- Friendly’s
- IHOP
- Denny’s
- 5 brothers fried chicken & waffles
- Flo’s Luncheonette
- Eastport Luncheonette
1. Crazy Crepe Cafe
Crazy Crepe Cafe doesn’t believe brunch should be bland or routine. With a menu built around both sweet and savory crepes, this spot has a knack for making simple ingredients feel like an event. The first time I stopped in, the scent of fresh batter and toasted wraps hinted at something special, and I left with a new favorite brunch tradition.
The savory Mediterranean crepe stands out—with spinach, feta, olives, and sun-dried tomatoes, it balances comfort with just enough tang. For a sweeter craving, the mixed berry crepe feels like brunch and dessert in one. Each plate comes out fresh and folds up everything you want in a midday meal—light, satisfying, and impossible to find elsewhere in Selden.
2. Cella Bagel
Sometimes, brunch calls for the kind of bagel you dream about—the ones with a crackly crust and pillowy inside. Cella Bagel gets this right every single time. Stepping in feels like joining a regular crowd who already know the secret: these bagels are something special. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve lingered at the counter, caught between sweet and savory choices.
The spinach and cheese bagel or the classic egg and cheese on a sesame bagel are personal go-tos. Both are filling, warm, and made fresh. If you lean sweet, their cinnamon raisin with a smear of plain cream cheese is a gentle nod to childhood breakfast but with grown-up quality.
3. Tropical Smoothie Cafe
Tropical Smoothie Cafe brings a splash of sunshine to brunch in Selden. If you’ve ever needed a midday pick-me-up or just a break from typical diner fare, this spot answers with color and fresh flavors. My first visit happened on a rushed morning, and I left feeling lighter but somehow full—no small feat for a quick brunch stop.
The Sunrise Sunset smoothie is the standout; it’s fruity, bright, and tastes like a vacation in a cup. Pair it with the Hummus Veggie Wrap for something filling but not heavy. These picks do a great job showing off the cafe’s style—fresh, quick, and always balanced. It’s the perfect spot when you want brunch without slowing down.
4. Caffe Amici
Caffe Amici feels like a little escape to Italy without leaving Selden. From the moment you walk in, the warm atmosphere and buzzing kitchen make it clear this place is a neighborhood favorite. I once stopped by on a lazy Sunday and found the dining room alive with families and friends sharing long, relaxed meals.
The ricotta and spinach omelet is a winner, creamy enough to feel indulgent but balanced with that fresh leafy taste. If you want something on the sweeter side, the Italian-style French toast, dusted with a hint of cinnamon, is a strong bet. Every dish here shows off Caffe Amici’s knack for simple food made with care. It’s the sort of spot that turns an ordinary brunch into a treat.
5. Friendly’s
Friendly’s in Selden has a way of making brunch feel a bit nostalgic. It’s the kind of place where everyone—families, college friends, or anyone in need of a cozy morning—finds a familiar table. I’ve found myself here more times than I can count, drawn in by the aroma of brewed coffee and pancakes on the griddle.
The Garden Vegetable Omelet deserves special mention. It’s fresh, hearty, and pairs perfectly with a side of golden home fries. Those with a sweet tooth will appreciate the strawberry banana pancakes, which always arrive fluffy and bright. Friendly’s isn’t about showy trends; it’s about comfort and consistency, served up in generous portions every time.
6. IHOP
IHOP in Ronkonkoma is the home base for classic brunch lovers. You never leave hungry, and whether you stop in at sunrise or the tail end of morning, the staff keeps the vibe genuinely cheerful. My last visit came after a long road trip and instantly hit the reset button with the comfort of bottomless coffee and pancakes.
The veggie omelet here is a solid order. Packed with fresh vegetables and paired with their signature hash browns, it offers both balance and fullness. Of course, skipping their buttermilk pancakes feels almost criminal—they’re fluffy, slightly sweet, and made for syrup drizzles. IHOP’s menu keeps brunch simple, well-priced, and always satisfying, which is exactly why so many keep returning.
7. Denny’s
Denny’s at Centereach Mall is the diner that always delivers on comfort, 24 hours a day. Sliding into a booth here feels familiar, whether it’s early morning or late afternoon. I’ve had more than a few ‘just one more cup’ moments, nursing coffee over a plate of breakfast favorites that feel like home cooking with a well-practiced touch.
The Veggie Skillet is a highlight. Sizzling veggies, seasoned potatoes, and perfectly cooked eggs arrive at your table still steaming. If you’re after something classic, order the Original Pancake Breakfast—fluffy, warm, and generously portioned. Denny’s stands out for its value and that unmistakable diner hum—making it an easy pick when brunch calls for reliable, satisfying plates at any hour.
8. 5 brothers fried chicken & waffles
(631) 438-0304Call
5 brothers fried chicken & waffles is the place you turn to when brunch needs bold flavors and a little Southern twist. The energy inside is as lively as the food itself—crispy, golden chicken paired with fluffy waffles stacked high. I dropped in once on a rainy morning and left convinced there really is no better pick-me-up than their signature combo.
The classic chicken & waffles plate shines with its crisp exterior and tender, seasoned meat, perfect for pairing with a drizzle of maple syrup or a side of spicy sauce. If you’re feeling adventurous, the sweet potato waffle adds something special with a subtle hint of sweetness. 5 brothers takes brunch staples and gives them a memorable, flavorful spin, making each visit unique.
9. Flo’s Luncheonette
Flo’s Luncheonette gives brunch a touch of retro charm without any fuss. You’ll find plenty of regulars swapping stories over coffee, and newcomers quickly understand why the spot has earned such a loyal following. The vibe is cheerful and relaxed—think summer morning, even if it’s gray outside. My first visit was pure luck, but I’ve returned for that feel-good atmosphere and hearty plates.
The avocado toast on grainy bread is a simple highlight. Topped with crisp greens and a squeeze of lemon, it’s fresh and filling without overdoing it. If you want something more classic, the buttermilk pancakes are fluffy and generous. Flo’s keeps the menu as warm as its service, making it the kind of brunch you’ll want to repeat.
10. Eastport Luncheonette
Eastport Luncheonette is the kind of spot that redefines “local classic.” The unpretentious setup and quick, friendly service make it a favorite for anyone craving brunch the old-school way. My visit started with a friendly smile and the comforting sizzle of eggs on the grill—the kind of sensory welcome you just don’t get everywhere.
The vegetable omelet is a clear standout. Each bite is loaded with crisp peppers, tomatoes, and a hint of cheese, all folded into eggs cooked just right. If you need something on the side, the golden home fries are hot and savory without being greasy. Eastport Luncheonette focuses on honest food that delivers every time, making brunch here feel refreshingly genuine.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best brunch spots in Selden, NY?
Crazy Crepe Cafe, Cella Bagel, and Caffe Amici top the list for their distinctive menus and friendly vibes. If you want classic brunch favorites, Friendly’s, IHOP, and Denny’s are always reliable choices.
Are there vegetarian brunch options in Selden?
Yes, many cafes and diners offer vegetarian-friendly plates. Try the spinach and cheese bagel at Cella Bagel, the veggie omelet at IHOP, or the Mediterranean crepe at Crazy Crepe Cafe.
Can I find healthy brunch options in Selden?
Absolutely. Tropical Smoothie Cafe offers fresh fruit smoothies and veggie wraps, while Flo’s Luncheonette serves a standout avocado toast and grain bowls for those looking to keep things light.
Is it easy to get brunch takeout in Selden?
Most brunch spots, including Crazy Crepe Cafe, Cella Bagel, and Tropical Smoothie Cafe, offer takeout. Many let you order ahead online or via phone, making the process seamless.
Are there kid-friendly brunch restaurants in Selden?
Definitely. Denny’s, IHOP, and Friendly’s all feature kid’s menus and relaxed atmospheres, making them easy picks for family brunch outings.