Finding the best brunch in Brookville, NY should never feel like scrolling through endless lists that lead nowhere. Brunch in this pocket of Long Island is both a local tradition and a low-key adventure. I remember my first foray: walking along a sleepy street, drawn in by the aroma of fresh coffee and the soft din of morning chatter—one plate of fluffy pancakes in, and brunch never tasted the same again. Brunch spots here have real character, serving satisfying classics and inventive twists, all while keeping it neighborly.
Brookville offers much more than the typical eggs-and-toast affair. Some places roll out homemade bagels that feel like a slice of New York comfort, while others feature crispy hash browns and slow-roasted coffee you won’t forget. Whether you crave hearty, sweet, or something off the beaten path, you’ll find a spot that draws you back for another round. Here’s a look at the best brunch places that Brookville and its surrounding area have to offer—get ready, because the search for your new weekend favorite starts now.
Where to find the best brunch in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best brunch in Brookville, NY:
- Denny’s
- ihop
- The Shed Restaurant – Westbury NY
- Yard Flavors Restaurant
- L L Dent Restaurant
- Mineola Eats
- Bagel Works
- Park Luncheonette
- Gerard’s Luncheonette
1. Denny’s
Denny’s at 371 Old Country Rd in Carle Place is equal parts familiar and reliably delicious. There’s a comfort in sliding into a booth here—especially when the aroma of fresh coffee greets you. I’ve spent many mornings here, enjoying easy conversation and classic brunch plates that feel like home.
Denny’s stands out for its all-day breakfast menu, perfect for those who don’t believe noon means choosing lunch over pancakes. The Strawberry Pancake Puppies offer a sweet twist, while the Build Your Own Grand Slam lets you craft your ideal meal.
Their versatility means you can keep it simple with scrambled eggs and hash browns or get hearty with a veggie omelet. It’s a brunch spot where variety never sacrifices quality.
2. ihop
If you’re seeking brunch that’s both uplifting and reliable, ihop in Westbury is a local legend for a reason. The ambiance is warm and cheerful, buzzing with the sound of sizzling griddles. I stopped by last fall and, to this day, keep coming back for their decadent stacks and bottomless options.
ihop stands out for its inventive pancakes that somehow feel as fun as they are comforting. Their Classic Buttermilk Pancakes are the undeniable favorite—fluffy, golden, and paired with a cappuccino, hard to resist.
If you want something a little different, the Veggie Omelette is satisfying and fresh. It’s the kind of meal that reminds you brunch should never feel complicated, just consistently good.
3. The Shed Restaurant – Westbury NY
The Shed Restaurant in Westbury is the kind of spot that invites you to linger longer than planned. The rustic, beachy vibe is relaxing, and the staff always seem genuinely happy to see you. My first visit stretched from a quick brunch to a slow, sunny afternoon of good food and even better coffee.
The Shed stands out with its all-day brunch, making it a hit for late risers and brunch fanatics alike. Their menu covers comfort food classics with a creative touch, served in generous portions.
If you drop in, the Avocado Smash is creamy, fresh, and perfect for a light bite, while the Garden Omelet is packed with seasonal vegetables. Both are a nod to their bright, healthy, and satisfying approach to brunch.
4. Yard Flavors Restaurant
Yard Flavors Restaurant in Elmont brings a fresh twist to brunch you won’t find just anywhere. The vibe leans easygoing, with friendly staff who remember your name if you’re even a semi-regular. On my last visit, the cozy space buzzed with groups sharing good food and laughter—a genuine neighborhood gem.
What sets Yard Flavors apart is its bold spin on classic brunch dishes. Expect family-style comfort with plenty of flavor and thoughtful presentation, making each plate feel homemade and special.
For brunch, the Callaloo and Ackee Platter is a satisfying, unique option—packed with greens, flavor, and just enough spice. Their Vegetable Omelet offers a lighter but equally tasty choice, highlighting local produce and a flair for wholesome eating.
5. L L Dent Restaurant
(516) 742-0940Call
For a brunch that feels like Sunday home cooking, L L Dent Restaurant on Old Country Rd is hard to match. There’s a warmth to the atmosphere; most regulars treat it like an extension of their own kitchens. My visit turned into a slow meal, with friendly staff suggesting favorites and the chatter of happy diners filling the cozy space.
L L Dent stands out for its soul food and buffet options. The portions are generous and every bite feels made with care. Their menu is rooted in American comfort with some home-cooked Southern influences.
For brunch, try the vegetarian hash with home fries. It’s hearty and flavorful, perfect for anyone who loves brunch with personality. The buttermilk pancakes are light, fluffy, and pair well with a fresh cup of coffee—simple pleasures in every sense.
6. Mineola Eats
(516) 741-0379Call
Stepping into Mineola Eats always feels like you’ve discovered a local secret. The diner hums along with the morning crowd, a cozy spot where regulars say hi to the staff by name. I remember sharing laughs over endless cups of coffee and thick, golden slices of challah French toast here—simple moments, high on comfort.
What sets Mineola Eats apart is its menu of well-executed brunch classics—reliable, unfussy, and tasty. The focus here is on quality and consistency, a winning combo for any brunch-goer.
If you stop by, the three-egg veggie omelet is stuffed with fresh vegetables and pairs perfectly with crispy home fries. Their homemade blueberry pancakes are another favorite: soft, sweet, and generously portioned.
7. Bagel Works
When it comes to bagels, Bagel Works in Huntington is in a league of its own. The scent of freshly baked bagels greets you before you even step inside, setting the tone for a top-notch brunch. I came here after a morning hike, and nothing hit the spot quite like their chewy, warm bagels—each bite proof of real craftsmanship.
Bagel Works stands out for its variety and quality, offering everything from classic plain to sesame and everything bagels. Each is crisp on the outside and perfectly soft on the inside, a true New York staple.
For brunch, the veggie cream cheese on a toasted everything bagel is a crowd-pleaser, loaded with flavor and freshness. Their lox and scallion bagel also showcases just how well they do the classics.
8. Park Luncheonette
(516) 741-1566Call
Park Luncheonette in New Hyde Park is a classic spot where the coffee is always hot and the vibe transports you straight into a Norman Rockwell painting. My morning ritual here includes sharing friendly banter with staff who seem to know everyone by name. There’s something timeless about a place that gets the basics exactly right.
What sets Park Luncheonette apart is its unfussy, hearty brunch menu. Satisfaction comes in the form of golden home fries, perfectly scrambled eggs, and a side of toast just the way you like it.
The vegetable omelet is packed with fresh ingredients and never greasy. For something filling and simple, the grilled cheese on rye fits the bill, especially with a bowl of their homemade soup.
9. Gerard’s Luncheonette
(631) 423-9035Call
Gerard’s Luncheonette in Huntington is the kind of place where brunch feels welcoming from the moment you walk in. There’s a vintage charm here, with counter stools and the gentle clatter of dishes that give you that true hometown-diner feel. I once spent a lazy Saturday morning perched at the counter, sipping a perfectly brewed cup of coffee while catching up with friends.
What makes Gerard’s stand out is its commitment to classic brunch favorites. The food is always fresh, served quickly, and never fussy. It’s the type of menu that satisfies every time.
The Greek omelet is a local favorite—packed with spinach, tomatoes, and feta for a burst of fresh flavor. If you’re craving something sweet, their blueberry pancakes are a crowd-pleaser and seriously generous on the berries.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated brunch spots near Brookville, NY?
Some favorite spots include The Shed Restaurant, Mineola Eats, and Bagel Works. Each offers a unique brunch experience, from inventive omelets to fresh bagels made daily.
Is it easy to find vegetarian brunch options in Brookville, NY?
Definitely. Many local places feature vegetarian-friendly menus. Omelets, pancakes, veggie hash, and avocado toast are common choices across Brookville’s brunch scene.
Are there any family-friendly brunch spots in Brookville, NY?
Yes. Denny’s, Park Luncheonette, and L L Dent Restaurant are favorites for families thanks to spacious seating and kids’ menu options.
Do I need a reservation for brunch in Brookville, NY?
Reservations aren’t always necessary, but can be a good idea for popular spots or larger groups, especially on weekends.
What brunch dish is Brookville, NY known for?
The area leans into classics like fluffy pancakes, fresh omelets, and handmade bagels. These staples showcase Brookville’s love for satisfying, hearty brunch fare.